Brad, don't know if it's fair to call him a liar. If he had some type of eating disorder, he probably wouldn't be asking help of this forum. There are all types of reasons why someone might have a poor appetite. Sluggish digestion, hormone imbalance, to name two.
I agree that weight gainers and protein powders are just food. But many people can drink a liquid shake when they can't force down solid food. It's the same thing as a fast food addict who fills up on cheeseburgers and fries but still has room for a milkshake.
Look at gastric bypass surgery. They have to drink fortified shakes in order to get enough nutrients. Although someone who has had the surgery may only be able to eat a couple of tablespoons of solid food, they can take in a lot more liquified food at once.
Now, I agree with you. Real, healthy food should be the goal. But I know from personal experience that shakes can help you in that goal toward eating adequately, rather than just being a replacement.
Last edited by EricT; 09-08-2005 at 10:39 AM.
|